US asks UN weapons conference for five more years on nonbinding autonomous arms rules
The United States asked a United Nations weapons conference that opened in Geneva on November 16 to spend five more years drafting a voluntary document on lethal autonomous weapons, rather than negotiating a treaty. According to a US working paper dated November 4, the text would reach a first version in 2029, with updates in 2030 and 2031.
The American paper contends that a voluntary text would be easier to revise as the technology shifts, and that it would apply to all states simultaneously. A protocol, by contrast, would bind states only if they ratify it and once it takes effect. The paper further holds that the laws of war already apply to attacks made by autonomous systems.
A competing draft from Peru’s Ambassador Elmer Schialer Salcedo, chair of the committee handling the issue, circulated on October 23. It tells an expert group to draft a new protocol to the convention, meeting 15 days a year and delivering a draft to the 2028 meeting of member states. The US plan calls for experts to meet 10 days a year.
Decisions at the conference require consensus, so any one of the 128 member states could block either plan. Separately, seven countries, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama, submitted a proposal to launch negotiations on a legally binding agreement, as reported by the Associated Press.
The session did not reach the substance. Russia told the opening session it would adopt the agenda and rules of procedure only if non-state observers received a single speaking slot after states had finished their substantive items, the UN transcript shows. The Swiss president of the conference suspended the meeting until 3 p.m. Geneva time after no agreement was found.
Several delegations spoke against the Russian proposal. The United States said it “strongly supports the full participation of observers,” while Britain, Canada, Norway, Panama, Mexico and Austria also objected, according to the transcript cited by DroneXL. Belarus backed Russia.
Earlier that day, Guterres spoke by video and asked for a legally binding instrument with clear prohibitions, the reverse of the voluntary-text proposal. “Take action to prevent the use and spread of these merciless weapons,” he told delegates.
Russia's foreign ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, called it premature to speak of the moment having arrived for restrictions or bans on such systems, the Associated Press reported. Two diplomats separately told Reuters that a compromise could still emerge before the week ends, with binding, non-binding or mixed results possible.
Expert talks that ended on September 4 produced a consensus report defining a lethal autonomous weapon system as one able to identify, select and engage a target, causing loss of life, without intervention by its human operator. The report says human control is needed, and that it may be exercised directly or indirectly, including through measures taken before use.
According to Human Rights Watch, the US and Russia softened the expert report during its last week of talks. The group says the final text dropped references to ethics, and that its scope was narrowed to international humanitarian law alone. Of the 76 states the group says favor negotiations, 70 are parties to the convention.
On October 29, the General Assembly’s disarmament committee voted 163 to 5, with nine abstentions, to call on convention parties to move to negotiations on an instrument. The United States, Russia, Belarus, North Korea and Israel voted against, and China abstained.
The US rule is Department of Defense Directive 3000.09, last reissued in January 2023. It requires that weapons be designed so commanders and operators can exercise “appropriate levels of human judgment over the use of force.” A June 5 presidential memorandum, NSPM-11, gave the Pentagon 90 days to update it, a deadline DroneXL puts at about September 3.
According to DroneXL, no revised version of the directive has been reported in the defense trade press since then. On June 12, Arizona Senator Ruben Gallego wrote to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth asking how an accelerated rewrite would protect against friendly fire and civilian harm, and requested answers by June 26.